Request Free Consultation

Do I Have the Right to Refuse the Insurance Company’s Settlement Offer?

Request Free Consultation
August 14, 2023 Insurance

After suffering an injury, victims often find themselves amid complex and overwhelming insurance claims involving adjusters, paperwork, and settlement offers.

One common question during this process is, “Do I have the right to refuse the insurance company’s offer?”

Simply put, yes. You can refuse an initial settlement offer, as it may not cover the full extent of your injuries, lost income, and other damages.

Understanding the complexities of insurance claims can give you a better idea of how to move forward with a claim and recover the compensation you deserve.

Understanding Insurance Companies and Their Initial Offers

Insurance Company Settlement Offer

After an accident, the insurance company may promptly contact you. Most insurance companies want to process the claim and settle things quickly. They are, however, businesses and will minimize costs wherever possible.

The Role of Insurance Companies in Personal Injury Cases

Insurance companies play a significant role in personal injury cases. After an accident, the at-fault party’s insurance company opens an investigation and begins the claim process. This process usually entails reviewing the facts of the accident, determining fault, and estimating the damages.

Your personal injury lawyer in Denver can interact with the insurance company to negotiate fair compensation on the injured party’s behalf. The insurance company then determines how much compensation to offer and pays it to the injured party.

The Nature of Initial Settlement Offers and Why They Might Prove Inadequate

The first settlement offer from an insurance company might seem impressive at first glance, especially when facing mounting medical bills and lost earnings. However, these initial offers typically will not fully account for your damages, pain, and suffering.

Other lingering costs that should be part of your compensation may not initially appear, including ongoing medical treatments, therapy, future lost income, and other related expenses. The services of a lawyer who can assess these initial offers and advocate for your best interests are vital.

The Rights of Accident Victims in Refusing an Offer

Understanding your rights as an accident victim is essential for making informed decisions throughout your personal injury claim process. One of your most critical rights is refusing an initial settlement offer. Whether to do so will depend on your current situation, the legal implications, and how rejecting or accepting that offer could influence your future finances.

An experienced lawyer can guide you through the decision-making process so you understand the potential benefits and implications of refusing an offer.

Factors to Consider When Thinking About Refusing an Offer

Deciding whether to accept or refuse an offer should include an in-depth evaluation of many factors related to the accident and your losses.

1. Your Physical Injuries and the Cost of Medical Care

To determine whether a settlement offer reflects your needs, you may need to study the cost of medical care for your injuries carefully. If you suffered relatively minor injuries, such as fractures or minor soft tissue damage, you may have a quick road to recovery and lower medical bills. If you suffer major injuries, you may have huge emergency medical costs and the need to finance long-term care.

2. Your Financial Losses

To evaluate your insurance company’s settlement offer, you may need to closely examine your large-scale financial losses related to the accident.

What impact did your injuries have on your income or your capacity to earn money? Did you have to miss time at work because of the accident? Some severe injuries may lead to a permanent career change due to lost faculties necessary for your current job.

3. Your Non-Financial Losses

A fair injury settlement typically includes the financial damages you sustained during the accident and the non-financial losses pertaining to your injuries. Accidents can lead to enormous suffering: the physical pain of your injuries, the emotional distress accompanying lost opportunities or independence, and changed relationships with loved ones.

You may have post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, or depression because of your injuries and sustained losses. Discuss the compensation you may deserve for those losses with your attorney to better understand how you can include them as part of a comprehensive injury claim.

4. Your Insurance Coverage

Your attorney may study your insurance coverage related to the accident. Some policies have higher limits and values than others. Your insurance policy may cover the compensation you request, and your lawyer may sometimes note that it offers coverage in areas you did not expect, which could increase the compensation you can recover.

Your lawyer may also examine which of your insurance policies may cover your injuries and damages. Suppose, for example, that you suffered injuries in a car accident. Carrying MedPay insurance that compensates for your immediate medical costs can offer more financial assistance. Your personal medical insurance may also provide substantial help after an accident.

Hire a lawyer to review all your policies. With their services, you’ll better understand the coverage your policies provide. Your lawyer can review any terms that could extend the financial protection you can claim. They can sometimes find ways to exceed the stated policy limits, providing you with the funds you need to move forward with life after an accident.

5. Your Long-Term Financial Needs

In evaluating a settlement, do not limit your deliberation to the impact your injuries have on your short-term financial needs; include their effect on your long-term financial situation.

Will your accident prevent you from performing job tasks necessary for advancement? Will you need to change jobs because of your injuries? What about your ongoing medical needs?

Talk to your lawyer about how your injuries have changed your life and how you can include those financial and non-financial losses in your insurance claim.

6. Your Timeline

Declining a settlement offer means you return to negotiation and will not immediately receive compensation for your accident. If you have a tight financial timeline and no options, you may accept a settlement rather than fight for future compensation. However, once you have signed a release of claims (which is typically required prior to receiving your settlement check), you will not be able to ask for any additional compensation for future care, permanent injuries, or future loss of income.

The decision of whether to accept a settlement offer from the insurance company is often highly personal. It depends on how much the insurance company offers you, your future financial needs, and your options for your future. Discussing your needs with an attorney can guide you toward the best decision.

The Role of a Lawyer in Negotiating With Insurance Companies

Denver Personal Injury Attorneys

Having a lawyer represent you in handling and negotiating your claim with insurance companies can transform the trajectory of your case. A personal injury lawyer brings legal know-how and offers guidance during these trying times. Their role extends beyond obtaining fair compensation and can drastically simplify the landscape of personal injury law.

Your personal injury lawyer can evaluate the adequacy of your insurance companies’ settlement offers. They can assess the extent of your physical injuries, emotional trauma, and financial losses to determine the fairness of an offer. Drawing upon their legal knowledge and experience, your lawyer can target a compensation amount that reflects the pain and suffering you endured because of the accident.

A Lawyer Can Renegotiate for a Higher Settlement

Refusing an initial offer may lead to renegotiations, a process where your lawyer can prove indispensable. Insurance companies may insist on settling for the lowest possible amount to minimize costs. Armed with evidence and an understanding of your unique situation, your lawyer can effectively argue for a higher settlement, focusing on all aspects of your physical expenses and non-physical losses.

The negotiations can involve extensive discussions and exchanges, a far less daunting process with a competent lawyer. A personal injury lawyer can leverage their knowledge of legal negotiation tactics to advocate for a more favorable settlement, ensuring you receive fair compensation for your losses.

The Value a Lawyer Can Bring to Your Case

While navigating the personal injury claim process independently may be tempting, the value of working with a lawyer can far outweigh the effort. With their legal knowledge, attention to detail, and dedicated guidance, a lawyer can significantly influence the outcome of your case, assisting in ways beyond legal representation.

Collecting and Sorting Evidence

In a personal injury claim, evidence is crucial in establishing fault and determining the extent of damages. Your lawyer can gather necessary evidence, including accident reports, medical records, witness statements, and expert testimonies. Your legal team can also handle the extensive paperwork, ensuring it aligns with legal requirements and deadlines.

Entrusting these critical aspects to experienced professionals ensures you do not overlook or mishandle any crucial evidence, increasing the likelihood of a successful claim. Working with your lawyer allows you to focus on your recovery without the stress of navigating complex legal procedures and paperwork.

Providing Emotional Support

Dealing with a personal injury claim can be emotionally challenging. The pain and suffering from your injuries and the stress of navigating the legal landscape can feel overwhelming. Having a lawyer during this time can provide reassurance. With an attorney, you can understand the complexities of your situation, devise a strategic plan to claim your rightful compensation, and receive emotional support, offering you peace of mind during a difficult time.

Increasing Compensation

Many people find that working with a personal injury lawyer dramatically increases the compensation they can recover from their insurance company after a severe accident, even after taking care of legal fees.

Most lawyers accept claims on a contingent fee basis, which means your fee will be a percentage of the settlement your lawyer wins on your behalf, eliminating the need for an upfront payment.

The Complexities of Personal Injury Law

Personal injury law is intricate and multifaceted, filled with legal jargon, procedures, and nuances that can be challenging to grasp for those unversed in the law. Dealing with various injuries and their legal implications amplifies this complexity. Having a seasoned lawyer by your side can significantly simplify this intimidating landscape.

Personal injury cases can originate from a broad spectrum of injuries, each with unique legal implications. Whether it’s a spinal cord injury from a car accident or a slip and fall injury, such as a broken hip or head injury at a public venue, the nature of the injury, the circumstances surrounding it, and their legal implications can significantly vary.

A personal injury lawyer with extensive legal knowledge can discover the legal ramifications of your specific injury, giving you a more accurate and personal insight into your case. As a result, you can feel more confident negotiating with the insurance company for the compensation you deserve.

Contact a Lawyer About Your Personal Injury Claim

Reaching the end of your personal injury claim journey is an accomplishment that often comes with relief and a sense of justice. Throughout this process, a personal injury lawyer’s valuable input and support can make all the difference in outcomes and experience.

Contact an attorney as soon as possible after the incident to find out how much compensation you may deserve and to negotiate with the insurance company for a fair settlement.